Social media was once a revolutionary tool that allowed people to connect with friends, family, and communities around the world. It fostered genuine conversations, creating spaces where diverse voices could be heard. However, in recent years, there has been a fundamental shift. Social platforms have evolved from encouraging authentic social interaction to prioritising engagement-driven content. Today, social media is often more about likes, shares, and follower counts than meaningful dialogue. This trend has been fueled by new platforms like Threads and Bluesky, which, despite initial promises of authentic engagement, quickly mirrored the superficial engagement strategies of their predecessors.

The Rise of Engagement Over Authentic Interaction

In the past, the primary function of social media was to enable meaningful connections. Now, the landscape has shifted, emphasising metrics and algorithmic engagement over user experience.

The Pursuit of Popularity

Social media success is often measured by numbers—likes, shares, and follower counts. This has shifted the focus away from building genuine connections toward achieving popularity. Many users strive for viral content, prioritizing engagement over authenticity. This drive for recognition has contributed to:

• Clickbait Content: Sensational headlines and provocative statements dominate social media feeds. Instead of stimulating thoughtful discussion, these posts aim to attract clicks, leading to a decline in the quality of interactions.

• Echo Chambers: Algorithms promote content aligned with users' existing beliefs, creating echo chambers that limit exposure to diverse perspectives. This restricts genuine dialogue and reinforces divisive viewpoints.

• Superficial Connections: Networking has become more about accumulating followers than forming meaningful relationships, resulting in surface-level interactions devoid of substance.

The Impact of New Platforms and Trends

The introduction of platforms like Threads and Bluesky brought renewed hope for genuine social interaction. Unfortunately, these platforms have also succumbed to the lure of engagement-driven content.

Threads and Bluesky's Initial Promises

When Threads and Bluesky launched, many users saw them as opportunities to break free from the engagement-centric culture of older platforms. Initial posts were often optimistic, with users seeking authentic connections and meaningful conversations. However, the excitement was short-lived.

Mass Exodus from Twitter/X and Behavioral Carryover

As users migrated from Twitter/X to newer platforms, they brought with them deeply ingrained behaviors centered around engagement metrics. This led to the rapid adoption of similar patterns seen on older platforms—competition for likes, superficial interactions, and clickbait content.

Challenges Facing New Platforms

Breaking the engagement-focused cycle has proven difficult. Despite their efforts to encourage more authentic exchanges, Threads and Bluesky struggle to differentiate themselves from established platforms. This underscores the challenge of changing deeply entrenched user behaviors.

The Forgotten "Social" in Social Media

The essence of social media lies in fostering meaningful conversations and building communities. However, this core purpose has been overshadowed by the pursuit of engagement metrics.

One-Way Communication Culture

Many social media posts are designed to attract reactions rather than initiate meaningful dialogues. Instead of two-way conversations, users often broadcast content with the sole aim of gaining likes, comments, and shares.

Metrics Over Meaning

The emphasis on numbers skews social interactions. Posts that generate high engagement may not necessarily promote meaningful discourse. In fact, many viral posts are designed for maximum reach rather than fostering genuine connections or thoughtful exchanges.

Reddit as a Case Study

Platforms like Reddit offer an alternative model, where genuine conversation still thrives. Subreddits, or user-driven communities, promote in-depth discussions centered around shared interests. Reddit’s upvote system rewards valuable contributions, allowing content with substance to rise to the top while low-effort posts are pushed aside. The anonymity it offers also encourages users to express themselves honestly without the constraints of personal branding.

The Emergence of "Engagement Media"

Given the current state of social platforms, the term "social media" feels inadequate. "Engagement Media" better describes the transformation that has taken place.

Algorithmic Prioritization of Content

Algorithms are designed to keep users engaged on platforms for as long as possible. This often means promoting sensational, polarizing, or emotionally charged content that maximizes user interaction. As a result, nuanced, meaningful posts are often overshadowed by content that triggers quick reactions.

Commercialization of User Attention

User attention has become a commodity. Social media platforms leverage engagement metrics to maximize advertising revenue, which influences the type of content promoted. This commercialization often prioritizes quantity over quality, leading to a less fulfilling user experience.

Consequences of Engagement-Centric Platforms

The focus on engagement metrics over genuine interaction has led to several negative outcomes.

Spread of Misinformation and Sensationalism

Clickbait headlines and sensational posts thrive on engagement-driven platforms, contributing to the spread of false or misleading information. This has serious implications for public discourse and trust in social media.

Decreased User Satisfaction and Isolation

Despite high levels of online activity, many users report feeling isolated and dissatisfied. The superficial nature of many interactions can exacerbate loneliness, as genuine connections are replaced by fleeting engagements.

Trust Erosion in Social Platforms

The prevalence of clickbait and low-value content has eroded trust in social media. Users are increasingly skeptical of the authenticity of what they see, further diminishing their experience.

Strategies for Promoting Genuine Connections

It is still possible to reclaim social media’s original purpose—fostering meaningful conversations and authentic connections. Both users and platforms have a role to play.

Mindful Posting and Content Creation

Users can start by creating content with intent, focusing on sparking thoughtful discourse rather than chasing likes. Posts that inform, engage, or reflect genuine interests are more likely to foster meaningful conversations.

Engaging Authentically

Engaging authentically means taking the time to comment, ask questions, and participate thoughtfully. By supporting voices that contribute positively to discussions, users can shift the focus back to meaningful exchanges.

Community Building and Supportive Behavior

Joining or creating groups that foster in-depth conversations and a sense of belonging can help build positive spaces within social media. Community-driven initiatives have the power to counteract the effects of engagement-focused content.

Conclusion

The transformation of social media into "Engagement Media" marks a significant shift in how online platforms operate and how users interact with them. The emphasis on popularity and metrics has led to a less fulfilling social experience, but it is not irreversible. By consciously choosing to engage authentically and prioritize genuine connections, users can help bring the "social" back to social media. This requires a collective effort to focus on building relationships rather than chasing numbers.

Call to Action

To help revive meaningful conversations on social media:

• Engage Authentically: Prioritize real interactions over metrics.

• Support Quality Content: Like, share, and comment on posts that contribute value.

• Create Thoughtful Content: Share posts that encourage genuine dialogue.

• Build Communities: Join or create spaces that foster enriching conversations.

By taking these steps, we can collectively shift social media back toward its original purpose—connecting people and fostering authentic interactions.